Skip to Content. Skip to Navigation.

Our Say

 
 

Crunch time for Blues

18/06/2009 1:01 PM


It's crunch time for Carlton this week.

The Blues simply have to beat arch-rivals Essendon at the MCG on Friday night if they are to be regarded as genuine contenders this season and not just an overrated bunch of pretenders.

Carlton has not made the finals since 2001 but has emerged from the darkest period in its history this season under coach Brett Ratten and with the split round now completed is sitting in seventh place with six wins and six losses.

Given the club has finished no higher than 11th since its last finals appearance and has finished either 15th or 16th in five of the past seven seasons - this appears to be a good performance.

But the only problem is the expectation on Carlton this season was that it was going to perform even better and those expectations were not just from the outside but inside the club as well.

Remember the club's membership slogan this year was 'They Know We're Coming' - a slogan that suggested a team capable of doing far more than just scraping into the top eight in 2009.

Given the leadership of Chris Judd, Nick Stevens and Heath Scotland and with recent No.1 draft picks Bryce Gibbs, Marc Murphy and ruckman Matthew Kreuzer all maturing nicely and having one of the game's best spearheads in Brendan Fevola and one of the best small forwards in Eddie Betts at their disposal, the Blues were considered at the very least certainties to make the eight in 2009.

But if they lose to Essendon on Friday night, the Blues win/loss record will not only fall into the negative but depending on other results they could also fall from the top eight with just nine rounds remaining.

Essendon is sitting in eighth spot, just percentage behind the Blues, and while Carlton is seen to have underachieved this season - the Bombers have definitely overachieved.

Yet if the Bombers beat Carlton, for what would be the fifth successive time on Friday night, Matthew Knights' young team would suddenly find itself above Carlton on the ladder.

Apart from perhaps the most one-eyed Essendon fan - and there are plenty of those in Victoria - few footy fans would have predicted the Bombers to finish ahead of Carlton this year.

The Blues, courtesy of their continual top draft picks in recent seasons following so many low finishes on the ladder, should be far further advanced in their re-building stage than

 
Page12»
Comments
Posted by Michael Jordan at
22/06/2009 04:51 PM
Try getting your facts right. In rd 12 Carlton on average was 1yr 3months younger and 20.2 games less experienced. How do figure they have more experience?
Posted by Heather at
22/06/2009 07:14 PM
Essendon at an average age of 24.8 years were the sixth oldest team of Round 12. I wouldn't call them young and inexperienced at all. In Round 11, Melbourne were older than Collingwood, and the Magpies also has more players that had played 50 matches or less. People have got to look at the age of each team before they start calling certain teams young or not.
Posted by Robyn @ Carlton at
22/06/2009 09:06 PM
Sorry Paul, but I don;t think there has been an expectation within the club. 2010 is what is expected withtin, the slogan created unfortunately created external hype. I beleive carlton will get into the 8, and yes this week is crucial.
Posted by George at
23/06/2009 12:33 AM
"the bulk of Carlton's list should be coming into their peak years" Geez you've jumped the gun a bit there. A couple of 20yo ruckman. 20-22yo defenders and a few 21 & under midfileders. Get some perspective!
Posted by I'm Right at
23/06/2009 03:05 PM
"Michael Jordan" try getting your facts right. The Essendon list has less games experience on average and a younger team on average than blues - fact. Add to this that 3 bomber players have 32% of the teams total games played there is a huge experience difference. I won't comment on blues tanking and high draft picks over the last decade as we are all aware of this.
Posted by Steve at
23/06/2009 03:55 PM
In recent years Carlton has cheated, rorted and tanked their way to their current position. Even if they scrape into the 8 this year they will not be serious contenders for the Grand Final.
Posted by Michael Jordan at
23/06/2009 08:19 PM
"I'm Right" that might matter if the whole list was playing!
Submit a comment
Name
Email
Comment

Latest Headlines

 
 
Fisher out for a month
Fisher out for a month
AFL
14/03/2010 9:12 PM
St Kilda has suffered a blow ahead of round one with star defender Sam Fisher injuring ...
 
 
Wake-up call for Saints
AFL
14/03/2010 12:31 PM
 
Hall keeping the lid on
AFL
14/03/2010 8:27 AM
 
Hall inspires Dogs
AFL
13/03/2010 9:46 PM
 
Injured Crows may return
AFL
13/03/2010 4:16 PM
 
Kreuzer on the ball
AFL
13/03/2010 12:40 PM
 
Lovett meeting fails
AFL
12/03/2010 8:44 PM
 
AFL ponders new format
AFL
12/03/2010 7:46 PM
 
Crows eclipse Blues
AFL
12/03/2010 6:51 PM
 
Demetriou slams Bingle camp
AFL
12/03/2010 6:15 PM
 
 
 

Your Say