Skip to Content. Skip to Navigation.

News

 
 
Ball faces ultimatum

Ball faces ultimatum

09/10/2009 3:43 PM

Former St Kilda captain and best and fairest winner Luke Ball could be on his way to Melbourne after the Saints failed to agree to a trade deal to send the star midfielder to Collingwood on the final day of AFL trade week.

Ball was the one big name that failed in his bid to change clubs in a trade week that saw 23 players change clubs - well up on last year's measly tally of six.

And not only did Ball fail to get to the club of his choice but the Saints have now withdrawn their previous offer of a new three year contract for the 25-year-old, who was taken at pick two in the 2001 'super' draft either side of superstars Luke Hodge and Chris Judd.

Ball was keen to leave the Saints after being frustrated at the treatment he received from Lyon this year when he not only spent time in the VFL but even when he did play in the seniors was used sparingly on and off the bench despite his status at the club.

However the Saints rejected Collingwood's offer of two draft picks - selection numbers 25 and 62 - in exchange for Ball, who now has little option but to nominate for the pre-season draft where wooden spooners Melbourne have first pick and can now select him for nothing should they choose.

Speaking after Friday's 2pm trade deadline, Lyon hardly threw the welcome mat out for Ball in terms of a return to Moorabbin.

"He has two clear options," Lyon said of Ball.

"One is to come back to St Kilda and train and deliver the actions that get you get selected in the senior team or go in the pre-season draft and take your chances."

Lyon confirmed the club had 'rescinded' its previous offer of a new three year deal for Ball but denied there was now bad blood between the club and one of its most respected players.

"We need to go away and assess what has happened but we certainly respect Luke," he said.

"We just couldn't get a deal done - there was (draft picks) 25 and 62 on the table (from Collingwood) but we were unlikely to use 62 and in our view 25 wasn't going to get the deal done.'

"We didn't think that was an equitable deal so we stood our ground."

Lyon said the club had explained its position to Ball and said it was now up to the 2006 captain and 2007 co-captain 'to go away and assess what he wants to do'.

Despite bringing in Andrew Lovett from Essendon and Brett Peake from Fremantle during trade week, Lyon said the Saints still had room in their salary cap to accommodate a new deal for Ball should he decide to remain with the club.

The failure of Ball to get to his club of choice despite having served the Saints loyally for eight years and 142 games will again raise the spectre of free agency - which the AFL Players' Association has been pushing for to enable experienced players to be able to move to their club of choice more easily.

However AFL football operations manager Adrian Anderson said while he felt sorry for Ball, he said this year's trade period showed that free agency was not needed given the higher number of players that were able to find new homes compared to previous years.

He said that was due to several changes made by the AFL including enabling clubs to swap picks for picks, even when players weren't involved, as well as allowing rookies to be traded (which enabled Geelong ruckman Shane Mumford to move to Sydney) as well as allowing for AFL run mediation sessions to enable clubs at loggerheads to complete deals as occurred with the Shaun Burgoyne move from Port Adelaide to Hawthorn.

"The fact is we have had 23 players find new homes and the relaxed rules to enable trades to happen more freely is a good thing because it means a club that loses a player is getting something in return whereas obviously with free agency that would not produce the same result (with clubs losing players for nothing)," Anderson said.

 
Comments
Posted by Johnno at
09/10/2009 04:57 PM
Lyon, you are a two-faced grudge bearer, you're a fake and have failed to deliver your word, again. Another example of St Kilda's losing culture.
Posted by dan warna at
09/10/2009 06:18 PM
thank goodness we didn't let Eddie blackmail us. hope we keep ball, but another case of Big Head Eddie promising much and delivering little. One day Eddie and Collingwood will learn to deal fairly...maybe.
Posted by adem at
09/10/2009 07:08 PM
Why have a go at lyon he is making the best decision for the club. And it is proven the right decision because no other clubs want him either because he simply isn't a good player. He is VFL standard now.
Posted by craig jessop at
09/10/2009 07:44 PM
Lyon should look at the way geelong treat players during trade period. They always do the best for the player. I suppose that is why the cats have won 2 flags in two years and the saints have won a total of 1 in there entire history. I agree with Johnno. Looser culture.
Posted by Shazza at
10/10/2009 07:11 AM
Lyon should have done the right thing and got something in return for Ball. If he nominates for the draft they get nothing but screws a player (this was the intention i reckon) who deserved to be treated better, Pathetic.
Submit a comment
Name
Email
Comment

Mondayitis

 
 

Mondayitis

Every Monday Bruce Eva, Peter 'Crackers' Keenan and Paul Gough will look back over the round that's been and look forward to everything that's coming up. Click here for the latest episode.

 

Latest AFL Headlines

 
 
Carlton's life on Mars
Carlton's life on Mars
AFL
09/02/2010 12:27 PM
Carlton has announced that MARS will be its major sponsor for the next three years, with ...
 
 
Hall set for Dogs debut
AFL
09/02/2010 10:37 AM
 
Gumbleton setback
AFL
09/02/2010 10:37 AM
 
Power nab major sponsor
AFL
08/02/2010 7:41 PM
 
Blues don't want another Fev
AFL
08/02/2010 5:31 PM
 
Stokes cops huge ban
AFL
08/02/2010 4:47 PM
 
New rules for NAB Cup
AFL
08/02/2010 1:21 PM
 
Mayne sticks with Dockers
AFL
07/02/2010 12:08 PM
 
Cassisi retains Port captaincy
AFL
05/02/2010 2:22 PM
 
Stokes struggling to cope
AFL
04/02/2010 5:52 PM
 
 
 

Latest AFL Audio

 
 

Our Say

 
 
Bren O'Brien
AFL gets it half right
Bren O'Brien
Common sense and common stupidity have both made an appearance with the four new rules ...more
Paul Gough
Crackdown a welcome initiative
Paul Gough
The AFL's decision to finally crack down on 'stagers' is long overdue but in many ways ...more
 

Your Say