Skip to Content. Skip to Navigation.

Our Say

 
 

Will players ever learn?

14/05/2009 8:01 PM

The day after damning group sex allegations were raised against Matthew Johns and others on Four Corners, a builder friend of mine wanted to know if I'd heard about the foursome involving three prominent NRL players and a willing female.

"No, how many years ago was that," I asked.

"Years? About three weeks ago," came the reply.

I don't know whether it's true or not – and there are always plenty of rumours surrounding footy players – but it's believable.

As believable as the league star from the late 1970s-early 80s who told me about sex sessions at a local gym involving any number of willing females and players.

Just today a woman rang a Sydney talkback radio station to tell of her encounter with two well-known AFL players, accusing them of some sort of unwanted tag team contest in her bedroom.

We've also had a current, unnamed, representative league player come out to say David Gallop's threat to weed out undesirables and throw them out of the game will resonate little at 2am in a crowded bar.

That episodes like Cronulla's Christchurch scandal will continue to happen.

That players, under the influence of alcohol and peer pressure, will continue to take risks no matter what course the NRL puts them through or how many times the club's welfare officer explains right from wrong.

Most football players don't consider themselves superior to the rest of us.

But they are treated as being superior by a large majority of the general public.

Fact 1: Some women throw themselves at footballers;

Fact 2: The majority know how to behave appropriately and do the right thing;

Fact 3: A minority will risk putting their reputation – and that of their club and code – on the line by indulging in activities that may not match up to the moral standards set by those on the outside.

Yes, this author is a male and the slant here is from a male's perspective.

In no way can you can condone what happened in that Christchurch hotel in 2002 or on a dormitory bed at a Bathurst university.

"Horrific allegations," as one of my female friends said.

Agreed. 100 per cent.

But Matthew Johns has suffered a very heavy price for his moment of madness, losing his job, his reputation and putting his family though what wife Trish describes as 'a living hell'.

The woman known only as 'Clare' deserves our sympathy, understanding and any help that can be offered.

But please spare us the line about this being some sort of catalyst or a fork in the road as far as off-field behaviour of players.

Some of them will never get it.

As for many of those firing the shots at Johns and demanding others step forward to be burned at the stake, they either have short memories or live in homes devoid of mirrors.

The rattling you can hear is skeletons being hastily removed from closets.

 
Comments
Posted by bomberpye at
15/05/2009 10:42 PM
What Matty did was immoral there's no doubt , but he did not break any laws. The media in Australia has this ability to create these storms where everyone gets in their moral glasshouses and throws stones. It's almost a mob mentality and if you are the unlucky one in the crosshairs God help you and your family. I think we are turning into a pack of mindless hypocrites who have lost the ability to think for ourselves. Not everything you read is true; not every TV presenter or feminist expert knows the whole story.
Posted by moretoit at
16/05/2009 03:32 PM
Johns may have suffered a heavy price for his "moment of madness" but is it any worse than the price 'Clare' has paid for her moment of madness in thinking that these grown men might treat her with respect and then being too intimidated and scared to ask them to stop. And if Johns' wife has been through 'a living hell' what sort of hell has 'Clare' been living through?
Posted by Annie at
18/05/2009 04:07 AM
The night before Matty's infidelity was raked up again, I saw a program that showed women preparing to go to a hotel in Brisbane frequented by footballers with the express purpose of 'bedding' as many of them as possible. If they show so little responsibility and regard for their safety, why expect young men to be any different? If 'Clare' went back to a room with two players, she must have known what to expect, yet nobody asked her "Why?". Her complaint was that they ignored her, so why didn't she get up and leave? If she's so traumatised she had to move to Asia to get away from what happened, why on earth would she be bringing it up again, unless it was for the money? I feel very sorry for Matty and his family, as he is getting the blame for everybody else's stupidity, as well as his own. If the NZ police found no case to answer, why is he being found guilty by the press? Leave the man in peace! You've all had your pound of flesh, you vultures.
Posted by moretoit at
18/05/2009 02:29 PM
Some women wanting to sleep with many footballers in Brisbane has absolutley nothing to do with Clare's individual case. Clearly Clare did NOT know what to expect when she went back to that room. She went there with two of the players and it's unclear about what, if anything, was said about sex before they got there. Certainly 10 or 11 of them being there wasn't an understanding of the situation. "If they show so little responsibility and regard for their safety, why expect young men to be any different" Annie I think you are confusing where the safetly issue lays - I don't think anyone is suggesting that Clare presented a threat to those poor boys who outnumbered her and treated her like a bit of trash to be used and abused. Police may say that no law has been broken but what 'Matty' and his mates did was much more than 'infidelity' as you put it - it was cruel, humiliating and degrading. Shameful. What if Clare was your sister or your daughter?
Posted by Alan at
26/05/2009 01:32 AM
Why is poor Matty Johns copping all the flack for this incident. No self respecting woman would go back to a hotel room with 2 males withount knowing the consequences and what it would inevitably lead to. For christ sake was she so naive. And yes if it was my daughter I would ask the question what are you doing there in the first place. Having a game of Snakes and ladders. I think its about time some women took responsibility for their own actions and not cry wolf soon as a situation gets out of hand. Lets face it you went there on your own free will.Dont place yourself in this situation and it wont happen. And yes in Clares case, money does speak louder than words.Why bring it up after so long.
Posted by moretoit at
29/05/2009 07:00 PM
Wouldn't want to be your daughter Alan. Yes, Clare was obviously naive. She was over-awed by being paid attention by famous footballers. Clare was 19 at the time and was described by the policeman in charge of the investigation as a 'very young 19'. Yes, Clare was naive - is it fair punishment for naivity to be humiliated and degraded? Clare has spoken about it now because she wanted to warn other young and naive girls that not all men can be trusted in such situations. Pretty good advice it seems. She also spoke about it now because she is still affected by it. I'm prepared to be corrected, but to the best of my knowledge Clare was not paid any money for speaking about the issue.
Submit a comment
Name
Email
Comment

Latest Headlines

 
 
Roosters thump Wests
Roosters thump Wests
League
21/03/2010 4:50 PM
The resurgent Sydney Roosters have thumped an out-of-sorts Wests Tigers 44-32 to stay ...
 
 
Bellamy praises defence
Bellamy praises defence
League
21/03/2010 9:36 AM
Melbourne coach Craig Bellamy has credited his players' gutsy defence effort as the key ...
 
 
Cleary hails Vatuvei
Cleary hails Vatuvei
League
21/03/2010 9:33 AM
Many rugby league experts were quick to suggest folding on Warriors' ace-wing Manu ...
 
 
Cowboys reel in Panthers
League
20/03/2010 9:25 PM
 
Storm hold off Knights
League
20/03/2010 9:22 PM
 
Vatuvei ignites Warriors
League
20/03/2010 7:46 PM
 
We don't fear Storm
League
20/03/2010 4:06 PM
 
Moore slams refs
League
20/03/2010 11:42 AM
 
Storm happy on the road
League
20/03/2010 10:23 AM
 
Brett wins brother battle
League
20/03/2010 9:27 AM
 
 
 

Your Say

 
 

Galleries

 
 
NRL Round 1
16/03/2010 11:14 AM
The NRL was back with a bang for 2010 in an opening round that featured a number of old faces returning to the fray, along with the usual newcomers and a couple of results that went completely against the odds.
State Of Origin III
16/07/2009 12:32 AM
The Blues served it up to the Maroons in Brisbane to avoid the clean sweep.